Can a National Care Service work without clear governance? Social Care is just one aspect of the multiple areas where politics if failing the next generation…
Can a National Care Service work without clear governance? This rhetorical question is not what politicians want to answer. If they do be sure to ask yourself in what length of time do their plans and strategy begin to bear fruit? It is the reason why we need a NextGen party. The worst aspects is the post code rationing and different rules and interpretation of the legislation in different dispensations. Continuing care applications are usually refused unless legal representation is resorted to.
| Governance in social care: lessons for reform from the Nuffield Trust |
| With social care high on the political agenda, our new report with the Institute for Government explores how governance and stewardship of the system could be improved as part of plans for a National Care Service. Commissioned by the Casey Commission, the report draws on learning and experience from social care’s own history, other public services and other countries’ social care systems. It was covered by the Guardian, Daily Mail and Independent, among others. |
No denial. Do we need a new party? The “NEXTGEN” party to take the Moral High Ground.
Health Care Leader briefing: Reducing NEET rate should be formal ICB target, Milburn review concludes

No denial. Do we need a new party? The “NEXTGEN” party to take the Moral High Ground.
There is good news out there. If global warming brings new diseases like Malaria and Ebola ….
There is good news out there. If global warming brings new diseases like Malaria and Ebola ….and vaccinations for Malaria and Ebola are looking good, along with public health campaigns across Africa This is explained beautifully in the BBC World Service . Ten years of progress -People Fixing The World is really “good news” for a warming world.
It seems ironic that an epidemic of Measles is rising in the G8 countries, and USA and UK are included in this. The irresponsible Robert J F Kennedy has managed to reverse decades of improvement in his short time in office as the Secretary of the U.S. department of health and Human Services. NHSreality has always supported vaccinations but the new threat of more diseases is real. Hers immunity is different for differing illnesses, and Measles has a need for over 90% coverage. Listen to the podcast from the BBC and feel inspired.
As a matter of interest this brings to the fore the dissonance between personal doctors who look after patients, and public health doctors who look after populations. As the health crisis develops, and it becomes apparent that we cannot afford all “cures” for free, the politicians will need to put public health first. Rationing has to become overt.
12th November 2026: Sky News: US loses measles-free status amid worst outbreak in 35 years – – for failing to prevent the virus spreading for more than a year.

12th November 1016: Emily Stearn for the Sun reports: Docs issue urgent warning to Gen Z and millennial women as cases of highly contagious Victorian disease surge across UK
There’s a new threat from Mosquito born diseases and global warming
The Economist: October 2026.The Ebola epidemic is getting out of control and spreading to countries around Africa and particularly adjacent to the Congo.
Where you live should not determine the healthcare you receive…..
Life expectancy is less the further you live from a tertiary centre, and especially in left behind coasal areas. If we increase the resources for rural areas, we are in effect reducing them in the tertiary centres. These are the centres of excellence we all hope to be treated in when our number comes up on the health lottery. Dr Whitty contemplates whether the policy of closing hospitals in rural areas might be reversed. This would be popular in the shires, where community “care” and “kindness” are often focussed.
Eleanor Hayward November 4th in The Times: Dreaming of a rural retirement? Beware the health risks – Chris Whitty, England’s chief medical officer, urges people to be clear-eyed about the potential downsides of life in the countryside Many of us dream of a quiet retirement in the countryside, picturing scenic long walks with fresh air and farmyard animals.
But Professor Sir Chris Whitty has urged people to be clear-eyed about the potential downsides of moving to rural areas when it comes to our health.
He highlighted “practical issues” of life in the country, including a lack of public transport, fewer supermarkets, poorer GP access and housing that is unsuitable for elderly people.
Twenty-eight per cent of the rural population are over the age of 65, compared with 12 per cent of the population in London. “Cities remain forever young. People come into cities at 18 and tend to leave after their second child,” he said.
Whitty, England’s chief medical officer, said there has “been a tradition in the UK for a long time” of moving from a city to the country for retirement.
“There are clear advantages, where people can make use of the rural environment for walks and for the pleasures of being in green spaces.”
But there are also “particular challenges”, he said, urging people to “be quite clear-eyed when they go into moving from an urban area to a rural area where they don’t have links”.
He said: “You often end up with people who move as a couple to a rural area, then one of them becomes incapacitated or dies before the other. They can often be left isolated or as a carer in a relatively isolated area, and they don’t have a group of people necessarily around them to support them.”
Another big downside is that “a car is a necessity” in rural areas, Whitty said, particularly to access hospital and GP appointments. Many elderly patients are no longer able to drive due to poor eyesight. “You’re in a car-dependent society, but without a car, that leads to a big gap in terms of access to healthcare,” he said.
Whitty’s annual report, titled Health in Rural Areas and Small Towns, called for a new “national strategy for rural healthcare”.
Rates of chronic diseases such as heart disease, cancer and stroke are much higher in rural areas because there are “many more older people” there, yet the NHS concentrates its resources in big cities.
“A lot of the burden of disease in the country is in rural areas, because that’s where older people live. In my view that is not reflected in the planning or provision of services,” Whitty said.
Overall about 9.7 million people, 17 per cent of the population, live in rural areas, and Whitty said that the challenges of caring for this group will increase as the population ages.
One of his key recommendations was for new housebuilding projects in rural areas to be adapted to suit frail and elderly residents.
“We ought to be making all new houses in these areas possible for someone to age in and maintain their independence,” he said, recommending adaptations such as “doors big enough for a Zimmer frame to get through” and a downstairs bathroom.
He added that the NHS should make better use of virtual appointments for patients living in rural areas, to save them long trips to and from hospitals or GPs.
He urged the NHS to adapt to the “unique needs” of rural workers such as farmers, who often do not have time to attend GP appointments.
Daily Briefing newsletter
Get our top stories and exclusive analysis sent straight to your inbox every morning.Sign up with one click
Ellie Houlston, the author of the report, who is director of public health at Derbyshire county council, highlighted the success of local schemes including doing blood pressure and cholesterol checks for farmers on market days.
She added: “I think it’s important for people to recognise that living in a rural area is a different way of life to living in a city. They need to go into it clear-eyed about what is involved.
“There’s not always the availability of services. You can’t ring up and order food online, for example. You can’t get a taxi very easily, if at all, in rural areas. So it’s a very different way of life, and you have to think differently about it and prepare differently for it.”
Dame Diana Johnson, the public health and patient safety minister, said: “Where you live shouldn’t determine the healthcare you receive, which is why we are taking action to close the gap for people in small towns and rural communities.
“We’re bringing more care closer to home through Neighbourhood Health and Community Diagnostic Centres, investing a record £14bn in GP services and making NHS funding fairer, so people can get the care they need, wherever they live.”
Letters 7th November 2026: Country retirement
Sir, Professor Sir Chris Whitty says rates of chronic diseases are higher in rural areas as there are many more older people there, yet the NHS concentrates its resources in cities (“A rural retirement could be bad for your health, warns Whitty”, Nov 4; letters, Nov 5 & 6). Services are more cheaply provided in urban areas, and Britain is an overwhelmingly urban society. If you are not required to live in the country but make a lifestyle choice, you should cover the additional costs yourself or forgo the services.
Paul Green
Croydon
Rural retirement
Sir, Professor Sir Chris Whitty is right to highlight the health inequalities and practical challenges facing people living in rural communities (“A rural retirement could be bad for your health, warns Whitty”, Nov 4). However, I would caution against allowing the narrative to become one in which rural retirement is viewed primarily as a health risk.
As a GP working in rural Somerset, I see both sides of this every day. Rural living can bring isolation, transport difficulties and barriers to accessing healthcare, particularly for older and more vulnerable patients. But it also offers enormous benefits: community spirit, social connection, physical activity and a quality of life that can be profoundly beneficial to health and wellbeing.
We should not be warning people off rural retirement; instead, we should be making rural communities places where people can age safely, independently and well. That means properly resourcing rural GP services, improving transport links and recognising that healthcare provision cannot be planned around population density alone.
Dr Tom Russell
GP, North Curry, Somerset
Rural ruminations
Sir, I live in the country and agree with all the points Professor Sir Chris Whitty makes (“A rural retirement could be bad for your health”, Nov 4; letter, Nov 5) except for his idea that the NHS should offer more virtual appointments for people living in rural areas. What has not been recognised is the poor access in the countryside to internet and mobile signals — and in some cases no access at all. We are indeed poor country cousins.
Ann Helsby
Bridge, Somerset
Sir, Could someone please tell Professor Sir Chris Whitty that compared with cities the countryside is healthier because it is quieter and greener, the air is fresher, neighbours are friendlier and more helpful and there are footpaths for peaceful walks.
Hyder Ali Pirwany
Okehampton, Devon
Shaun Lintern 7th November 2026: Train rural GPs to end overprescribing crisis, says Chris Whitty – England’s chief medical officer has backed a Sunday Times campaign on the dangers of mixing pills, particularly outside cities where most elderly people live
Family doctors in rural England need more training to help tackle an overprescribing epidemic among the elderly, England’s chief medical officer has said.
Professor Sir Chris Whitty welcomed The Sunday Times’s campaign on problems with polypharmacy, which is defined as taking five or more medicines.
Patients who take a series of interacting drugs can face dangerous side-effects such as falls, dizziness and irregular heart rhythms. The issue is blamed for putting up to 1,000 elderly people a day in hospital.
“Polypharmacy is a significant problem,” Whitty said. “I’m very pleased The Sunday Times is campaigning on it. It’s something people need to be aware of.”
Almost eight million people in the UK take five or more prescribed drugs daily. About 2.2 million take ten a day.
Whitty said there was a “tendency” for patients in hospital to leave with more prescribed drugs than they went in with, “without people necessarily thinking through how you can cut things down”. He added: “I do think it’s something we need to train people very seriously on. I think in general practice and geriatrics, it’s taken for granted. I think it’s not always as well thought through in all other specialties.”
He said GPs in rural areas need specific training in polypharmacy and how to tackle it because they would be disproportionately caring for older patients who would have amassed numerous prescriptions.
Whitty was speaking at the release of his annual report, which this year focused on the problems facing England’s rural areas, where 9.7 million people live — more than the entire population of London.
He said these areas were ageing faster than cities. Place such as London and Manchester remained perpetually young, because older people tended to move out to the countryside and young people into to urban areas.
Whitty said rural GPs — whom he described as the “bedrock of small town health” — would face greater challenges in looking after their populations.
In 2024, 28 per cent of adults in smaller rural areas in England were aged 65 or over, compared with just 12 per cent in London. This gap would become “even more extreme” over the next two decades, Whitty said.
“Anyone who is dealing with older patients will be dealing with people who have over time potentially accumulated a number of drugs, each one of which was given for a logical reason, but the combined effect of which is no longer the optimal one for that person,” he said.
“The more frail people become, very often, the more significant a side-effect that previously would not have been a problem becomes one. If you drop your blood pressure a bit when you stand up, that may not be a problem when you’re in your mid sixties but may be a significant problem when you’re in your late seventies. I think people should be getting training, GPs in particular, working in these areas.” The Sunday Times has called for more training for younger doctors managing medicines for frail, older patients; regular medication reviews for the over-65s; and training for more specialist geriatricians.
The ageing population is presenting a growing challenge to the NHS. The first baby boomers turn 80 this year.
Whitty, who still works on the wards as a consultant physician at University College London Hospitals, said the NHS needed a dedicated strategy to provide the right care for the older population outside cities. This could include reversing the closure of smaller cottage hospitals over the past three decades and boosting digital services for the isolated.
Whitty also called for better care for military families and a change to the type of housing being built in rural areas so people could grow old and stay in their homes.
He wants more GPs and other doctors to be exposed to working in rural areas and for medical schools to expand placements in small towns.
A study published in BMJ Medicine has shown that a computer tool could help GP practices identify patients most at risk from the effects of their medicines.
The tool helps highlight patients taking one of 88 common drugs, known as anticholinergic medicines. These block the chemical acetylcholine, which is vital for cells to communicate with each other. The drugs can increase the risk of dementia and have side-effects including falls, blurred vision, delirium and confusion as well as dry mouth and constipation.
Dr Kate Best from the University of Leeds, the study’s first author, said: “While an anticholinergic medication might sometimes be the best treatment, with so many drugs that have this unintended side-effect, anticholinergic burden can easily accumulate and pose a significant risk.”
The anticholinergic medication index uses electronic patient records to flag those aged over 65 with a high risk score. It was tested using data from 750,000 adults and piloted in GP surgeries in Bradford, where it generated a list of patients for review by GPs who previously would have had to manually calculate the risk for each patient.
The index is also beginning to be used in hospitals, where it can recalculate a patient’s risk as they are prescribed new medicines. The team are testing the tool in geriatric medicine and orthopaedic hip fracture wards to examine the feasibility of a wider introduction in secondary care.


Going backwards, with my Granny, and the same for hip fracture related deaths..
When my mothers mother was about 88 she fell in Stourbridge. The local hospital put her on a ward and told my mother that the operation would be done in a week’s time. I was a final year medical student and we discussed the problem with her team, we said that death would likely follow if she had delayed surgery, but the consultant was unmoved. There was no local theatre time. He did however have private time and we chose to pay, not only for the speed but also for the pain relief. A simple K nail was inserted and she was walking shortly afterwards. Unfortunately dementia was coming and accelerated by the admission (a common situation) and the family ended up questioning whether we were right. She lived another 4-5 years in a nursing home sharing a room with another elderly lady with no dementia but immobile. My granny helped get things for her, and her friend was her advocate when her lack of sensible speech meant she could not be understood. He operation did indeed prolong her life. And she may not have become demented after the surgery. It was a chance we took and I would like the same chance to be given to me.
The recent reports of deaths after fractured neck of femur are disturbing. Even a 3 days wait is a risk, dehydration and chest infection from lying flat, pressure sores from not mobilising, and accelerating mental decline from the confusion of a new environment. We seem to have gone backwards because these patients have little agency apart from their relatives. The consultant in charge of admissions is not usually the one who operates, and there are no “firms” or teams providing continuity of care. Single people without relatives are particularly at risk, but the data do not break this down as yet. Many hospitals, including my own DGH in West Wales are still writing on paper notes the very data that should be collected and would be helpful. The nurses, over-managed, are collecting much useless data and admonished if they fail to measure temperature, BP and Oxygen saturation 6 times daily, when what the patient and their family want is “care”, explanation and a sympathetic ear.
If we are to persist in this undervaluing of older people we will eventually solve the waiting lists with the excess deaths increase. How many have an assertive advocate? How many have the means to pay privately? The rationing of care in HIP fracture treatments is a disgrace. But this is a “Single Interest Pressure Group” with little agency…
The operation is done now with image guiding technology, but 40 years ago an image before and another afterwards was the norm. Once again the technological sludge has slowed us down, In the hands of a skilled operator who does them repeatedly, the nail fixations are simple and successful.
Ella Piclover
The crisis in care for those with hip fractures is a warning for all – An investigation has exposed that people are dying unnecessarily while waiting for treatment after falls, one of the most common reasons people end up in hospital Dr Mark Porter in the Times 26th October 2026.
I have been troubled by Shaun Lintern’s recent investigation in The Sunday Times, which revealed that people with broken hips “are dying unnecessarily at Nottingham hospitals trust after being left waiting too long for an operation”. It should concern you too — even if you haven’t broken anything and don’t live in the Nottingham area — because how well someone is cared for after fracturing a hip is a good marker of standards in any NHS hospital. And the problem isn’t limited to the East Midlands.
Hip fractures are common. At least 1 in 20 men and 1 in 7 women will break a hip at some stage, typically after a slip or fall. So it’s no surprise that as many as 1 in 30 NHS hospital beds are now occupied by someone with a hip fracture, either waiting for an operation to fix it or recovering from one.
Prompt care requires the smooth operation and coordination of several departments and teams: from A&E, where the problem is typically diagnosed, through to specialists in the care of older people (most will be over 75), surgeons, anaesthetists, theatre and ward staff, pharmacists and physiotherapists. These patients are often more frail than most, and can have multiple complex health issues ranging from underlying osteoporosis to heart and kidney disease, diabetes and dementia.
In general the quicker someone has surgery for a fractured hip — typically a break in the top of the thigh bone, just below the ball of the hip joint — the better. Options vary from screws and nails through to total hip replacement. Whatever the method, data suggest that you are likely to have the best outcome if operated on within 36 hours of admission.
The Sunday Times found that at least half of patients in Nottingham were waiting longer than this, a delay that could contribute to the higher mortality rate even when adjusted for variables such as the patient’s age and health. According to the newspaper 1 in 13 people admitted with a broken hip in Nottingham dies within 30 days, compared with a national average of 1 in 20.
For perspective, the long-term trends have been reassuring: in 2003 average mortality rates were closer to 11 per cent, but they haven’t improved in recent years. While Nottingham may be an outlier, it’s not the only NHS trust that is. Nationally about 4 out of 10 people still don’t get their operation in the timeframe set out by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (this advocates surgery on the day, or the day after admission rather than specifically within 36 hours), and there is worrying variation from hospital to hospital even when taking into account the different populations they serve.
Of course, there are good reasons why surgery may be delayed in individual cases, including underlying serious health issues, but these don’t account for the variation. A report from the national hip fracture database has turned up another potential issue: a quarter of people who break their hip have had a previous fracture that could have been a warning sign of weakened bones due to osteoporosis, and half of them are not receiving bone-strengthening medication.
This brings me on to prevention, a subject I have been banging on about in this column for years: the importance of never ignoring a fragility fracture such as breaking your wrist, hip or vertebra following a fall from standing height, or in the case of the spine sometimes after no apparent trauma. These injuries should always prompt further investigation and treatment to mitigate further bone loss.
Hospitals have become very aware of this and many have specialist teams — fracture liaison services — to pick up problems, initiate investigation and start treatment where required. However, according to the Royal Osteoporosis Society, nearly half of NHS trusts in England still don’t have such a service. This may not matter if your GP has been kept in the loop and arranges tests such as Dexa bone scans, and starts supplements and osteoporosis drugs, but too many people slip through the net.
And it’s not just about bones, but why you fell too. As well as having previous fragility fractures ignored, too many people who end up in hospital with a broken hip have a history of repeated falls. A history that could have alerted them and their doctors to problems ranging from balance issues and overtreatment of high blood pressure, to heart disease, poor vision and increasing frailty. GPs, community frailty teams and specialist falls clinics can look for underlying causes and mitigate them, but only if the problem is identified. All too often, by the time it is, it’s too late.
The seven questions to ask that might make a difference
There is no simple way to ensure you get timely, safe treatment but asking these questions might help, either yourself or on behalf of a relative or friend.
Am I on a planned trauma list for today or tomorrow?
Will I be seen by a specialist in the care of the elderly?
If surgery is delayed, why, and what’s being done in the meantime to prevent dehydration, provide pain relief and correct any issues picked up on routine pre-op investigations such as chest x-ray and blood tests?
What about my normal medication? Should I still be taking it?
Will I be out of bed the day after surgery?
What will be done to reduce the chances of a blood clot after surgery?
Who is arranging a follow-up bone-health assessment? Do I need to be referred to a falls clinic?
Ella Pickover in the Independent on 28th October 2026: One change that could prevent 50,000 bone fractures over five years
Shaun Lintern on 25th October: Hospitals in A&E crisis investigate hip fracture death rate – Surgery ought to be done within 36 hours of admission but Nottingham misses the target for half of them
Hospitals in A&E crisis investigate hip fracture death rate
Patients with broken hips are dying unnecessarily at Nottingham hospitals trust after being left waiting too long for an operation.
The trust has ordered an urgent independent investigation into the mortality rate of hip and leg fracture patients after surgeons found those waiting longer than 36 hours for emergency surgery had a 20 per cent higher mortality rate.
Data obtained by The Sunday Times shows the mortality rate for hip fracture patients in Nottingham is almost 50 per cent higher than the national average for hospitals in England.
The Nottingham University Hospitals Trust is one of the largest providers of hip fracture care in the UK, treating more than 850 patients a year.
It has declared a critical incident over record demand in its accident and emergency department. On Tuesday the hospital said there were more than 200 patients in A&E, with more than 100 waiting to be seen. 
Last week The Sunday Times revealed how A&E staff blew the whistle to the care watchdog, the Care Quality Commission, over dangerous overcrowding and the normalisation of poor A&E waits in emails to senior trust leaders. One clinician highlighted that an elderly patient had fallen and broken her hip trying to get off a trolley in a corridor.


Hip fractures in the elderly can be the most dangerous injuries they can suffer, often marking the beginning of a rapid and sometimes fatal decline.
National guidance requires patients to reach theatre within 36 hours of admission because delays are known to increase the risk of death. The Nottingham trust is failing to meet the target for half of hip fracture patients. Delays peaked at 55 per cent in May and 53 per cent in June.
For Maria Laney, it is a grim reminder of her mother’s final hours after she spent 24 hours on a trolley in the hospital’s A&E department in October 2022.
Sylvia Thomas, aged 77, from Edwalton, fell out of her A&E trolley while the emergency department was short staffed. The fall broke her hip. She had surgery but suffered a heart attack and died two weeks after her fall. Heart attacks are associated with hip fractures.
Laney, 56, said she was still living with guilt. “I rang them and I said, do you need me to come in? Because she needs one-to-one care and they said, ‘No, she’s going to the ward in a minute’.”
That never happened and her mother was left on the A&E unit until the following day. “They never told me they were short staffed,” Laney said. “If I knew they were short staffed, I’d have gone straight in. That is what’s killing me now.”
The trust apologised after an investigation and accepted there had been staffing gaps with too many patients.Surgeons at the trust gave a presentation on the care of hip fracture patients to a “learning from deaths committee” this month. At the meeting, Dan Deakin, an orthopaedic consultant, laid bare the trust’s poor performance this year.
In May there were 16 inpatient deaths among patients with non-hip lower limb fractures and two hip fracture patients. In total, 72 inpatient deaths were recorded across the two groups between March and September 2026, 20 hip fracture patients and 52 lower limb fractures.
The adjusted 30-day mortality rate for hip fractures at Nottingham has been rising for several years and has reached 7.62 per cent by the first quarter of 2026. This compares with a national average of 4.9 per cent.
A study carried out by Nottingham surgeons, published in The Bone & Joint Journal in August, examined more than 5,400 patients treated between 2016 and 2023.
A total of 1,490 patients suffered a delay to their surgery beyond 36 hours and this group was associated with a 20 per cent increase in one-year mortality. The longer the patient waited, the greater the risk of death.
Dr Chris Busby, one of the study’s authors, said: “Many hospitals are under pressure and there has been a large national focus on delays for elective surgical care such as hip and knee replacements.
“However, delays for emergency surgery also result in significant and avoidable patient harm. The oncoming wave of hip fractures, which is set to double in the next decade, will only make this worse. Radical investment in our emergency staffing and operating infrastructure is needed to save lives in this vulnerable patient population.”
A patient representative on the learning from deaths committee, wrote directly to Anthony May, the trust’s chief executive. The letter said: “I wish to express concern about the excess deaths occurring at NUH in patients presenting with hip and lower limb fractures.
“Most hip fracture patients are elderly. The elderly are entitled ethically and societally to the same access to healthcare — medical or surgical, as appropriate — as the young: cradle to grave. A further ethical responsibility of the trust is to prevent the moral injury of staff that occurs when, for reasons beyond their control, they are unable to provide timely and safe care.”
The trust has confirmed it was aware of the high mortality rate, which was discussed in a public meeting of the board this year. It has now asked the British Orthopaedic Association to carry out an urgent review.
Dr Manjeet Shehmar, medical director at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust, said: “Patient safety is our highest priority, and having received the recent mortality alert, we promptly commissioned an independent external review to identify any further action needed to improve care for patients.
“In the meantime, we have taken action to address the issues identified — investing in additional theatre capacity, increased staffing and strengthened training to ensure surgical waiting times for patients with fractured neck of femur are now falling, but we recognise there is more to do.”
Ella Pickover 26th October 2026: Universal access to early diagnosis and Fracture Liaison Services (FLS) in the UK would free up 338,579 acute NHS hospital bed days and prevent nearly 50,000 bone fractures over five years. and One change that could prevent 50,000 bone fractures over five years | The Independent

Is the QOF unethical ? As Wales Health descends slowly into chaos, a report implies the conspiracy of denial and the collusion of anonymity. Would this be a good definition of our health service?
If we think of the work done by a GP practice for QOF ( Quality and Outcomes Framework ) and that this is time taken away from diagnosis and treatment if individuals, is there an ethical issue here? Many other systems in other countries are short of doctors and their recruitment posters often say “no QOF” If a nation is failing for over 20 years, since devolution, and votes to persist with the same party we know something is wrong. To vote for an ever worse party which will persist in policies that make Wales more parochial is madness. Wales might have birthed the original NHS, but it has no way of being called “within” the current UK services. It uses different measuring parameters and performance indicators, it does not allow choice and life expectancy is 5 years lower than England. There really is no NHS any longer, despite the language of our political class. The persistent and increasing overspends, the free prescriptions and the focus on “prevention” for the future will mean that the safety net is not there when the lottery of life delivers a cancer needing urgent access, investigation and referral. Wales underperforms on all these aspects: hence the excess deaths Releasing the GPs from QOF would allow better access and a more open front door. It would not however deal with the back door of social care . When rationing gets deeper and is unacknowledged, private care and social divisions get worse. In these circumstances QOF is unethical.
Mark Mansfield reports 1st November for The Nation Cymru: Welsh NHS trapped in ‘doom loop’, former minister and health board chief warn
NHS Wales is trapped in a “doom loop” that leaves health leaders producing reports rather than improving care, a former Welsh Government Minister and an ex-health board chief have warned.
Lee Waters and former Hywel Dda chief executive Steve Moore are calling for fewer targets, clearer routes out of government intervention and practical support to cut waiting lists. “Every board is escalated, everyone is reporting, and too little time is left for the hard work of improvement,” Mr Moore said.
“You can’t fix everything at once. The answer is to fix the things that matter most first: waiting lists, fewer targets, and practical support to help services change.” Their paper, From Escalation to Improvement, also warns against breaking up Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board and argues that money alone will not resolve the health service’s problems.
It was written with Tim Daley and Victoria Ford of Swansea-based consultancy Perago. The paper declares that Perago and Mr Moore’s advisory business provide the kind of external improvement support it recommends. The Welsh Government said: “The new Accountability and Support Framework was introduced precisely to address the issues raised in the paper. It shifts the focus from process and reporting towards improvement, support and measurable outcomes, whilst maintaining appropriate accountability for performance and public resources.”
The authors’ analysis of all seven Welsh health boards between 2015 and August 2026 found that every board had been subject to some level of escalation since September 2023. Escalation ranges from additional monitoring to special measures. The authors argue that a process intended to flag exceptional concerns has become routine, absorbing the time and attention of staff responsible for improving services.
They want national performance measures reduced from 53 to fewer than ten, with a single reporting channel and published, measurable conditions for leaving intervention. The paper acknowledges that the Welsh Government’s Accountability and Support Framework, announced on September 29, offers an opportunity for change, but says success will depend on its implementation.
Waiting lists should be the first priority, with a national programme led by health board chief executives and medical directors aiming to make Wales the fastest-improving UK nation on planned treatment waits.
Teams involving clinicians, theatre and booking staff, managers, analysts and patients would identify successful approaches, test them locally and spread improvements across Wales. The report describes an unnamed Welsh hospital where theatre utilisation improved by around 20% after staff worked together to address delays. Those gains disappeared within months after the lead manager was moved to other work.
Victoria Ford, Perago’s managing director and group chief executive, said: “Big change starts small, with the people who do the work. But it only lasts if boards make improvement their main business, give teams, including clinicians, time to lead it and scrutinise whether it’s working.”
Sustained recovery
The authors identify Cwm Taf Morgannwg’s maternity and neonatal services as the clearest example of sustained recovery, moving from special measures in 2019 to routine arrangements in 2024 with independent oversight and published conditions.
They contrast this with Betsi Cadwaladr, which has remained under intervention at varying levels since June 2015. It left special measures in November 2020 before returning in February 2023.
Breaking up the north Wales board might be “politically attractive”, the paper says, but is “probably the worst option for tackling the underlying causes” of its difficulties.
Instead, the authors want Betsi to become the first test of a different approach to escalation, with realistic timescales and support to strengthen leadership and improvement capacity.
The paper cites a combined £199 million health board deficit in 2025–26, despite a 4.5% real-terms increase in revenue funding the previous year, as evidence that improvement must address how services are organised.
“This proposal is deliberately practical,” Mr Waters said. “Its first steps don’t need legislation, a new funding settlement or another reorganisation.”
The authors say urgent and emergency care requires a longer-term programme of investment in social care, rehabilitation and community services, rather than simply adding hospital beds and ambulances.
Confidence
Mr Waters warned that failing to improve NHS performance would have consequences for patients’ confidence in the service. “Unless we get a grip on this quickly more and more people are going to migrate to the private sector,” he said. “The numbers are still small, but they point to a slow unravelling of the social contract behind the NHS.”
Matthew Syed in the Sunday Times on growth, denial and anonymity 1st November 2026: We blame politicians for stagnation, but voters are the real problem – Every budget is a charade. Ministers know what drives growth, but they also know the electorate refuses to pay for it His remarks apply equally to the health services as to growth and the economy.
The Tenby Observer 31st October 2026: Hywel Dda University Health Board is facing a staggering £62 million underlying deficit, with the Welsh Government labeling its financial management as “unacceptable”
This is an accumulation of which this year’s projected deficit of 22 million is part. The management have no way to win this game under current rules.

Waste in Wales
A health board that plans to close primary care services at three hospitals in North Wales funded nurses in Africa.
The revelation led to further calls for Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board to be removed from the Senedd’s control, and run by the UK NHS.
The Health Board has announced it is consulting on plans to end urgent primary care centre services at Ysbyty Penrhos Stanley in Holyhead, Ysbyty Alltwen in Tremadog and Ysbyty Gwynedd in Bangor.
It blamed financial pressures for the plans, which campaigners say would have “dire consequences”But the Health Board’s decision to divert resources to projects outside the UK faced a backlash.
Under the Wales for Africa programme, which Plaid Cymru ministers continue to support, funding was awarded to the Health Board’s Bangor Masagna Link scheme.
It was granted £13,459.00 to provide courses for nurses and community health officers in Sierra Leone.
The Health Board has also taken part in separate projects in Namibia, Lesotho and Kenya.
Plaid Cymru Health Minister Mabon ap Gwynfor (pictured) has repeatedly refused to seek help from the UK NHS to address long standing problems in North Wales.
He insisted he will “not even countenance the idea”, arguing “we’ve got devolution” and the Health Board “answers to the Senedd”.
Plaid Cymru ministers’ failure to act has led Reform UK to call for the Health Board to instead be placed under the control of the UK Department for Health and Social Care.
The welfare trap – unfairness in provision leads to more demand in less privileged post codes. It could lead to movements between dispensations …
Doctors want good relationships with their patients, and they are well aware that more poverty means more medical demand and poor health. So they have a perverse incentive to give “A prescription for money” in the form of a certificate. A prescription is also a “gift” and much quicker than a long consultation. The perverse incentive to give either needs to be addressed and the first letter suggests a way out for certificates. In mental health we need counsellors rather than prescriptions for drugs, like France is attempting. Big Pharma seems to be more powerful than any other force and the perverse decision to fund US patented new drugs and raise the NICE QUALY year value could cost us dear. There is a real risk that poorer dispensations (Wales?) will be unable to afford as many or even any new treatments before patent expires. Post code rationing is going to get worse, and the two tier system is also going to lead to greater health divide and differences in life expectance. All we want is a fair system: we can accept rationing if its the price of universal equality – of both access, and treatment. Unfortunately devolution in health in an open society means moving dispensations when its necessary.
Letters 13th October: Times letters: How to fix Britain’s failing benefits system?
Sir, At last, your Welfare Inquiry is beginning to expose what some people have argued for years: the system is biased towards claimants at the expense of taxpayers (“Almost 2m on sickness benefit may not qualify”, news, Oct 12). The answer to welfare abuse is to replace family GPs as the gatekeeper and replace them with specially trained medics and paramedics. GPs are too quick to sign people off and in some cases are probably intimidated into doing so. This shift will cost money but should easily be paid for through savings, providing the Labour government has the courage to deny benefits to those fit enough to do some form of work, which I doubt.
Dr David Cottam
Castillonnès, France
Sir, Further to your leading article (“Caught in the Safety Net”, Oct 12), the onus appears to be on the government to reassess claimants who have been receiving benefits that are no longer relevant. Surely it makes more sense to put the onus on claimants. If the two million that The Times has identified were to receive a letter requiring them to provide written evidence of need within a given period, say three months, it would have a dramatic effect in reducing numbers. In the case of the taxi driver you highlight in your news articles, the response would be simple. He no longer needs it and hasn’t done for years. How many times is this replicated elsewhere?
Martin Lindsay
Colston Bassett, Notts
Sir, Your inquiry is to be welcomed. As resources for determining an individual’s right to sickness benefits seem to be prioritised towards new claimants, the solution to potentially never-ending payments seems obvious: stop the payments at the end of the term so that recipients are encouraged to reapply if they need it.
Chris Broyden
Richmond, Surrey
Sir, While I wait in anticipation of the publication of Alan Milburn’s review into why there are so many young people not in education, employment or training, we should address the legislation that acts as a barrier to teenagers getting work experience. I started work in my village bakery aged 12, working from 8am until 4pm with a half-hour break and earned about £10, which felt like a fortune in 1982. I then progressed to working in the chip shop at age 14, where I was able to work two evenings a week and a Saturday lunchtime and evening — and I kept on top of my schoolwork!Now young people, from 13, can only work a maximum of two hours on a school day and Sundays, and a maximum of five hours on a Saturday (eight hours if they are aged 15 to 16). In an increasingly secular society, why does the Sunday rule exist?
As a youth worker in a rural area, I know many young people who would love a part-time job in a café or hotel, but employers are hesitant or unable to take them on because they simply cannot employ them for the hours that they need. There are more ways for the government to help young people into employment without the need to offer grants and subsidies, and reviewing this legislation would be a cost-effective first step.
Kate Parish
Duntish, Dorset
The Times leader 13th October 2026: Our inquiry seeks a way out of the welfare trap – The Times is launching a six-month investigation of the benefits system
The delay of Alan Milburn’s report on Neets is an alarming sign. The number of young people not in employment, education or training is a crisis that deepens with each wasted month. The longer people stay out of work, the less likely they are to move into it: this is a pernicious trend observed throughout the western world. Urgency is needed. More hand-wringing is not.
Today The Times launches a six-month inquiry into welfare that seeks to expose more of the problems. Mr Milburn found that £25 is spent on youth benefit payments for every £1 spent on active employment support; across the whole welfare system, this newspaper has found, the ratio is closer to £40 to £1. Our system has become not one of helping people to work, but one of cheque-and-forget.Sickness benefit, for example, is intended in the main as temporary support.
Every day, more than 1,000 people are signed off as too sick to work. Most are given a prognosis period, after which an assessor will establish if they still qualify for support. But such reviews, we reveal, stopped during Covid and were never properly restarted.
Some 1.8 million people are beyond their due date; the average wait is two years and the longest a barely believable 16 years. Before lockdown, reassessments were regular and at their peak 380 people were judged fit to work every day. Last year’s average was 33 a day. It should not be assumed that claimants are delighted to be left alone. The Times interviewed a taxi driver who has recovered from heart surgery and told the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) he no longer needed the benefit. He was told he could not sign off and must wait to be reassessed. He will soon have been waiting for four years.
The Times will be looking at other aspects of the welfare state in the coming days and weeks. Pat McFadden, the work and pensions secretary, told us about the “pipeline” that conveys children to welfare. We will be exploring this, and the world of “supported accommodation” in which landlords charge more than twice normal rent. We will also examine the effects of crude welfare on those struggling with addiction, as well as children who fear that being medically “labelled” will condemn them to a worse life.
Labour entered office pledging to reform a broken welfare system but has paid heavily for its procrastination. The sickness and disability bill is expected to rise from £77bn to £110bn in this parliament, with a million more people lost to out-of-work sickness benefits. This is like losing a workforce the size of Bristol and Sheffield from the economy. While immigration can fill some gaps, it’s no way to run an economy.
A better discussion is needed. Tools exist to show the long-term impact on claimants. One DWP study of a large sickness benefit cohort found that just 0.3 per cent were off benefits and back in work two years after signing on. This suggests a staggering failure to serve those in the system. One part of the tragedy is that almost a million such claimants are under 35. The great majority want help to get off benefits but scant effort is made to provide it.
In his review of workplace sickness, Sir Charlie Mayfield estimated that every young person signed on to sickness benefit loses £1m in earnings over their lifetime, and costs the taxpayer the same. If his figures are halfway correct, ignoring 1.8 million sickness benefit claimants overdue for their checkup is leaving the taxpayer on the hook for unthinkable sums.
Mr McFadden is clear the system is not fit for purpose. That is why he commissioned Mr Milburn to identify problems and solutions. Delaying this discussion will be as tempting for Andy Burnham as it has been for his predecessors. But he must be the prime minister who finally stops kicking the can down the road. The time to act is now.
Revealed: Nearly two million on sickness benefits left unchecked
Mental health disability benefits ‘given to 400,000 more children’
Pricey cures, especially for large numbers, have to be rationed…. until patent expires
Thinking small and the “left shift” plans intended for health ( In England – not sure of the other 3 dispensations)
Left shift, right funds? The battle to move NHS money where it matters has been policy for some years, but the imperative for hospital funding always seems to trump primary care. Now that there is no continuity or out of hours commitment from most GPs, there is no staffing infrastructure ready to take on the necessary responsibility. How many GPs still cover palliative and terminal care at home in a personal way? The AI (Gemini) produced report below explains the problem for Ministers. The prospects don’t look good.
The NHS “neighbourhood money shift” (often called the “left shift”) refers to the policy goal of moving funding and healthcare delivery away from acute hospitals and into local, community-based and primary care services. [1, 2]
Core Funding Realities
No New Central Money: The shift relies on rebalancing and redirecting existing resources rather than injecting large amounts of brand-new central government funding. [1]
- The Acute Squeeze: Lord Darzi’s review highlighted that the share of the NHS budget spent on hospitals rose from 47% to 58% between 2006 and 2022, while community services grew by just 0.5% a year. Shifting money means acute trusts under massive waiting list pressures must contract or redesign care to release funds. [1, 2, 3]
- Local Commissioning: Integrated Care Boards (ICBs) hold the responsibility for shaping local neighbourhood contracts and determining how (or if) money actually flows from hospitals to community teams. [1, 2]
- Tiered Savings Timeline: Moving funds is generally envisioned across staggered phases—from cash-releasing urgent community responses (0–12 months) out to wider preventative and social prescribing pathways (24+ months). [1]
The Times letters 10th October 2026: Thinking small
Sir, Martin Lewis’s Small Ideas Initiative (“Finances guru funds bid to fix ‘the small stuff’”, Oct 8) seems a good idea but I also remember the one Wes Streeting set up when he took over as secretary of state for health. I and thousands of others contributed to that and many of the suggestions were very good, but it has quietly been forgotten. I suspect the same fate will befall this one.
David Goodwin
Lewes, E Sussex
Sir, Regarding Martin Lewis’s initiative, we should restore the family doctor to general practice (“Think small”, leading article, Oct 8).
Dr David Jeffrey
West Malvern, Worcs
Is any form of continuity in primary care possible, or is it also dying with the 4 health services?
We never trained enough doctors despite many applicants. Of those we have trained too many choose part time work. Strong leadership is needed to insist on enough doctors in emergency care – it might even mean threatening to remove a licence to practice if a doctor avoids emergency care commitment for more than two or three years.
Prof Hay opined on a future template for General Practice 2 months ago. This post has resulting correspondence, and the Prof’s reply. At least a debate has begun. With the shortage of GPs, Nurses and staff, poor recruitment and retention, and poor investment in infrastructure and IT there is no speedy recovery possible. The shape of the GP job is so restricted and over-managed with performance indicators, that since 2001 (see below) the job is no longer what my generation expected. A new generation of medical students experiences something completely different, and it is not appealing, except to those who no longer wish to be immersed in a job working as one of several essential persons in a community.
The Buxton Index measures the length of time (in years) over which an organization or individual makes its strategic plans, providing a useful lens in British Journal of General Practice discussions to highlight the mismatch between short-term political/commissioning horizons and the long-term relational continuity required in general practice.
Continuity of Care in General Practice
• Definition: Relational continuity involves an ongoing, trusted therapeutic relationship between a patient and a specific clinician or small team over time.
• Benefits: Regular consultations with the same GP improve trust, disclosure, and health outcomes while reducing overall consultation frequencies and hospital or A&E workloads [0.15].
• Measurement: The Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) recommends tracking relational stability using metrics like the Usual Provider Continuity (UPC) index, where a score of 85% is considered very good and 60% is creditable.
The Buxton Index Mismatch
• Short-Term Planning: Bureaucratic or corporate health frameworks often operate with a low Buxton Index (planning horizons of 1–2 years), prioritizing immediate access targets, quick transactional appointments, or short political NHS cycles.
• Long-Term Value: Building “accumulated knowledge” and relational trust takes roughly 15 consultations or years of longitudinal care, representing a high Buxton Index that clashes with rapid-fire, fragmented access models.
Would
Leader by Euan Lawson: Continuity of care and the Buxton Index | British Journal of General Practice 2026; 76 (771): 436
The two main protagonists in the story of primary care in the UK are often access and, ironically, hospitals. Too often, the narrative is about how primary care can reduce pressure on secondary care. The systems must work together but if the apparent raison d’être for primary care is to make life easy for hospitals, it spectacularly misses the point.
The evidence for continuity of care is substantial, is growing, and is verging on inarguable. Anyone arguing for more effective primary care in the long-term who doesn’t have it on the list to drive policy is going to fail. From the BJGP’s perspective, the article that landed was Sandvik et al’s 2022 article on the benefits of continuity of care in the Norwegian healthcare system.1 And, of course, the headline figures were about how it reduced pressure on hospital admissions and urgent care as well as reducing mortality.
The Buxton Index of a person or organisation is the number of years ahead over which they make their plans.2 Nowhere is this more apparent than in the need to adjust primary care systems to account for continuity of care. One of the benefits of the Buxton Index is simply to allow different organisations to communicate and understand each other without moral accusations. Access to care is important — but it has a low Buxton Index and relational continuity is all about a high Buxton Index. The Norwegian mortality data only really show up once you get past 15 years of the same GP. Politicians, and others, fixating on better access are not malign actors — they’re simply planning over incompatible periods compared to advocates of continuity of care.
The Buxton Index lens also holds at workforce level: a partner buying into premises has an index of ≥20 years, and the drift to salaried, locum and portfolio working is, structurally, a downward revision of general practice’s institutional Buxton Index. The long index is one of the great positives of partnership and an understandable reason why other drawbacks are tolerated. Continuity of care bring benefits for patients but it is also boon for GPs. It can add to GP satisfaction, anchoring doctors to place and to community. Seeing patients with whom you have existing relationships is not the same professional experience as spending a day on in front of a computer doing triage.
There is a fundamental problem with chronic underfunding for primary care and the NHS 10 Year Plan presents an opportunity to make the case for general practice, but we need to sketch out a vision that moves beyond the hospital/access narrative. Neighbourhood health schemes were launched half-baked, but as they develop let’s pay attention to the Buxton Index. Advocating for more funding for primary care without a policy approach that prioritises continuity of care will leave us with short-termism and perpetual crisis.
The delusions of doctors | British Journal of General Practice
Roger Jones opines: Think Twice |British Journal of General Practice 2017; 67 (665): 539. I trained to be a GP after a number of years as a hospital doctor. I had become comfortable with the laborious inductive methods used in internal medicine to arrive at a diagnosis. The diagnostic approaches used in general practice perplexed and intrigued me, and led me to the research of Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman, and their paper on making judgements in conditions of uncertainty.1 What was happening in general practice? I conducted a study involving all 20 GPs in a Hampshire market town, to whom I presented a series of vignettes of patients with dyspepsia, and asked them to tell me, for each vignette, what further information they would need to make a diagnosis or management plan, and conclude the consultation.2
There were large differences between doctors in the number and nature of the pieces of information that they required and the time taken to complete these ‘consultations’. In contrast with previous research there was no correlation between the professional experience of my subjects and the amount and nature of data they collected.
With hindsight, it was perfectly obvious that I was observing the interplay between Type 1 and Type 2 thinking, described in Kahneman’s 2011 book Thinking, Fast and Slow.3 I just couldn’t see it. I went on to edit the British Journal of General Practice. Kahneman went on to win the Nobel Prize in economics for his work on prospect theory and the psychology of judgement and decision making. But is he happy?
Type 1 reasoning is rapid, intuitive, automatic and unconscious; it generates the diagnosis that forms in our mind when we see a patient’s name on the surgery list, or observe her rising from the chair in the waiting room. Type 2 reasoning is slower, more logical, analytical, conscious and effortful. It includes the search for confirming and disconfirming evidence, obtaining and acting on the results of investigations, being willing to let go your earlier, cherished diagnosis, and recognising that relying on your personal heuristics — short cuts to diagnosis — may sometimes take you down a blind alley. Diagnostic safety-netting, if you like.
Diagnosis is the theme of this month’s BJGP, with articles related to many aspects of diagnosis in general practice. There are the challenges of making an accurate diagnosis when no diagnostic test is available, as in IBS, and the likely impacts of genomics, point-of-care testing, and computerised decision support systems. In the future these may have the capacity to synthesise the content of the electronic medical record with the presenting complaint, the clinical signs, and diagnostic tests, including genetic testing, in ways that are now just about imaginable. Observations like those made by Chris Burton and colleagues on the interplay of abdominal pain and pelvic symptoms in the years leading up to a final diagnosis of endometriosis are likely to form the substrate of these diagnostic support systems. Gentle reminders about considering coeliac disease in the IBS scenario, and hyperaldosteronism in the hypertension case could transform the role of the third person in the consultation: the computer.
One of the most compelling examples of Types 1 and 2 thinking, or at least of the difference between the intuitive and the empirical, in medicine is tangentially linked to Chris Murphy’s article about humility, in which the great Scottish philosopher David Hume plays a part. On his sick bed, Hume had gathered the wisest physicians of the day around him. They offered a range of diagnostic possibilities, which Hume considered fanciful, not least because no one had actually examined him. Fortunately he was visited by John Hunter, empiricism incarnate, who palpated Hume’s abdomen to find the malignant liver; giving Hume an answer for which he was immensely grateful. Think twice — it’s alright.
2011: RCGP-Continuity-of-Care.pdf Promoting Continuity of Care
in General Practice by Hill and Freeman
2019: Mark Rickenbach (RCGP) &George Freeman (Imperial College) RCGP-continuity-of-care-guide-141119.pdf RCGP Guidelines for Continuity of Care – Helping clinicians and practices maximise relationship continuity
GP continuity of care can be regained: lessons from Finland.
Alistair Hay: Author’s response | British Journal of General Practice British Journal of General Practice 2026; 76 (771): 449. I am grateful for the opportunity to respond to Professors Checkland1 and Marshall. I am pleased that the ‘vision’ (an entirely opinion-based article)1 has stimulated discussion and challenged ideas.
Challenging ideas in this area is important because: 1) many feel the system is broken and the status quo is no longer an option; 2) we rely heavily on opinion (while the evidence Marshall cites is suggestive,2–3,4,5 it is far from definitive — patients and carers able to navigate complex care systems and achieve continuity may also be the least likely to need further appointments and emergency hospital admissions); and 3) our ideas could be holding back the development primary care most needs.
I would also observe that our views have much in common: a) we agree that the more complex the patients’ needs, the more continuity is needed (my ‘vision’ would make that possible); and b) that we need high-quality evidence to inform strategy. As a senior clinician scientist, I would like to throw down the gauntlet and offer our ICB-based pragmatic cluster RCT platform6 as one method by which that evidence could be obtained.
Tom Marshall: Fragmentation by design | British Journal of General Practice British Journal of General Practice 2026; 76 (771): 448-449. Professor Hay articulates the opposite arguments from those I advanced in a previous article in the BJGP.1,2 This vision has, unfortunately, from the first sentence, rested on fallacies and untested hypotheses.
Access, continuity of care, and low cost are not competing objectives. Achieving one tends to improve achievement of the others.
Continuity and access are correlated at the level of general practice: those that achieve high continuity also achieve good access. This is easily observable in General Practice Patient Survey data. The Pearson correlation coefficient is 0.65 between the ‘continuity’ question (how often do you see your preferred clinician?) and the ‘access’ question (what was your experience of contacting your GP practice?). Higher continuity with an individual GP reduces demand for appointments (workload in general practice).3 It also results in lower antibiotic prescribing and reduced admissions to hospital.4,5 Therefore, it reduces costs in both primary and secondary care.
One of the key issues in general practice sustainability is staff retention. Low continuity is associated with higher staff turnover.6 Qualitative research identifies relational continuity as providing doctors with a sense of joy in their work.7 This is echoed in letters from GPs responding to the article.
In other words, practices that provide low-cost care tend to have good access and high continuity. Exactly the opposite of what is suggested.
These benefits appear to be linked to an individual relationship with an individual doctor. We have no evidence to support alternative models, such as GPs as leaders of a team of clinicians. From the responses to the article, the evidence is not appealing to many GPs. The article proposes something that would continue the current tendency towards fragmentation in general practice. But no evidence is advanced as to why this model would be superior. Existing evidence suggests this would increase demand for appointments, likely reduce access, and increase costs, while contributing to staff turnover. Proponents of such an approach should provide evidence to support the view that it would not.
5th September 2026: Sustaining a career in general practice: a qualitative study of experienced GPs in South West England | British Journal of General Practice “Future research should prioritise testing practical interventions to improve GP retention. Evaluation of redesigned triage and duty systems, administrative task sharing, or continuity pathways could clarify which organisational changes most effectively reduce workload and prevent burnout. Research should also explore whether experiences of workload intensity, moral distress, ability to ‘job craft’, and drivers of attrition and retention differ by ethnicity or gender. This is important to ensure future policies address the needs of a diverse workforce, especially with increasing numbers of international medical graduates working in UK general practice.26
In conclusion, experienced GPs described both the pressures pushing them out of the profession and the resources that help them stay. Addressing professional workload, autonomy, and identity is essential not only to retain experienced GPs but also to protect continuity, quality, and sustainability in primary care.”
Saul Miller is a GP in Wooler, Northumberland. Threadbare – BJGP Life “There is silence for a moment as we consider how an area like this would not sustain even a single GP if it needed private subscribers, almost regardless of the level set for those costs. Creating an equitable distribution of GPs was an NHS aim from its inception but the mechanism for that was abandoned in 2001, causing things to deteriorate already.4 But this would completely undo those 53 years of positive effort.”
August 2026: A possible template for a plan for the future of General Practice – who wants to be the fall guy?
Withybush downgrading and the risk of local unrest similar to the educational unrest in France
Crumbling infrastructure and lack of staff are longstanding and have been ignored in the UK. This is true of Hospitals and their IT, and their staffing. In Education as well as Health the short termism has won – for many elections. In Europe its similar. French students are feeling ignored. Fire and fury of France’s students as dozens of teachers left injured =Violent protests continue in lycées across the country, with one police officer left unconscious after being knocked to the ground and Pupils arrested after school protests spread across France – Students threw projectiles and set off fireworks to demonstrate against conditions at schools across the country . The same is true of the health services and its worse the further we live from a city or a tertiary hospital. The PISA educational standards in Wales are partly a reflection of the poor funding, the dysfunctional politics and the unreality of Welsh expectations. Withybush Hospital ( and its RAAC ) should be pulled down and, like most hospitals, replaced with a plastic and cardboard structures with a 10 year life expectancy. The history of Hospitals in the Pembrokeshire County Town goes back centuries, but a modern hospital with all the facilities seems unaffordable in today’s “managed decline”. Devolution has failed the citizens of Wales.
Gilderdale Jackie’s post 6th October 2026:
Save Withybush Action Team on Facebook
Thank you for your response. I have to say, however, that I find your decision to decline a meeting with representatives of the Save Withybush Campaign extremely disappointing and difficult to reconcile with the assurances contained within your letter.
You acknowledge virtually every concern we have raised; patient journeys, ambulance capacity and response times, rurality, equality, service resilience, transparency and the long term future of Withybush. You also state that patient safety must be the overriding priority and that proposed changes must be supported by robust clinical evidence.
That is precisely why we have asked to meet you.
This is not about bypassing Hywel Dda University Health Board or interfering with its statutory responsibilities. It is about Ministerial accountability and proper democratic scrutiny of decisions affecting the health and safety of an entire rural population.
Your letter places considerable emphasis on the fact that Hywel Dda is the statutory body responsible for planning and delivering healthcare services. However, that does not mean Welsh Government has no role or powers in relation to the Health Board.
As Health Minister, you are part of the Welsh Government that holds statutory powers of direction and intervention in relation to NHS Wales bodies. The NHS (Wales) Act 2006 provides Welsh Ministers with powers to direct Local Health Boards, while the Welsh Government’s own NHS Wales oversight framework expressly provides for Welsh Government intervention where serious problems require external support. (Legislation.gov.uk)
Indeed, Welsh Government has demonstrated that these powers can be used when it considers intervention necessary. In 2024, Welsh Ministers used their powers under Section 12(3) of the NHS (Wales) Act 2006 to direct Hywel Dda and Swansea Bay University Health Boards to establish a Joint Committee. (GOV.WALES)
More recently, Welsh Government has also taken direct action in relation to another NHS Wales health board, demonstrating that ministerial oversight is not merely theoretical. (GOV.WALES)
Therefore, with respect, we cannot simply accept the suggestion that responsibility rests entirely with Hywel Dda and that our concerns should therefore remain within the Health Board’s existing processes.
The electorate and patients of Pembrokeshire expect their Health Minister to use the powers available to Welsh Government when there are serious concerns about patient safety, access, clinical resilience, transparency and the future provision of essential healthcare services.
We are not asking you to prejudge any proposal or to take decisions that properly belong to the Health Board. We are asking you to exercise the oversight and accountability that comes with your ministerial responsibilities and to hear directly from the people who will be affected by these decisions.
You say that patient safety must remain the overriding priority. You say that decisions must be supported by robust clinical evidence. You recognise the particular challenges faced by rural communities.
You acknowledge concerns about ambulance capacity, response times, equality, resilience and transparency. Then surely the people raising those concerns deserve to be heard by the Minister responsible for Health and Care.
It is also not sufficient simply to tell us that our concerns have been “carefully noted” and passed into established oversight arrangements. Communities need more than their concerns being noted. They need answers, evidence, accountability and action.
The Save Withybush Campaign has demonstrated an extraordinary level of commitment to protecting healthcare services in Pembrokeshire. These are patients, residents, families and community representatives; people who have every right to expect meaningful engagement from the Welsh Government.
We are not asking you to undermine Hywel Dda. We are asking you to scrutinise it.
We are not asking you to prejudge clinical decisions. We are asking you to ensure that those decisions are based on robust evidence, patient safety and the realities of rural Pembrokeshire.
And we are certainly not asking you to take sides. We are asking you to listen. You have acknowledged the concerns. You have acknowledged the importance of rurality. You have acknowledged the importance of patient safety. You have acknowledged the need for robust clinical evidence. Now we need you to engage.
I therefore ask you to reconsider your decision and agree to meet representatives of the Save Withybush Campaign, alongside myself and other community representatives.
Withybush Hospital is not simply a building or an administrative responsibility of a Health Board. It is a vital part of the healthcare infrastructure of rural Pembrokeshire. Decisions affecting emergency care, surgery, maternity, stroke, paediatrics and other services have potentially profound consequences for patients and families who cannot simply be treated as statistics or told to travel ever further for care.
As Health Minister, you have both the responsibility and the statutory framework within which Welsh Government can oversee and, where necessary, intervene in NHS Wales.
The people of Pembrokeshire are entitled to expect those responsibilities and powers to be taken seriously when the future of their local hospital and the safety of its patients are at stake.
Our campaign will continue to seek the evidence, ask the difficult questions and hold the relevant bodies to account.
We hope you will reconsider your refusal to meet us. The people of Pembrokeshire deserve nothing less.
There’s no fair social care rationing, or funding provision. Different dispensations and Trusts and Post Codes treat everyone differently..
Social care is a minefield of inequality unfairness resentment poorly paid staff and discontent. NHSreality has opined on Social Care on many occasions, and as it is the back door it needs to take citizens so that others can get into the front door. But care at home and in the community is costly, and we don’t seem willing to pay. Indeed the defence of the realm and internal security might be higher priorities for many voters. Although hospices are very popular, some do not take demented patients, and funding is unequal and random. Much depends on the affluence of your area. Hospice at home would cost much less and could include immobile demented patients. Funding could reward improved percentages and including dementia. Means tested co-payments are all very well, and insurance based additions are possible, but the big problem will be the mobile demented who may be living alone …. If these people are dangerous to others or themselves, how does the state have the ability to care for them?
Sunday Times letters 12th October 2026: Difficulty accessing free social care
Rachel Mortimer is right to highlight the barriers to accessing care that is free at the point of use (business, Oct 4). NHS Continuing Healthcare in England is not means-tested, yet only about a fifth of standard applications succeed, and integrated care boards apply the national criteria differently.
The application by the 81-year-old man in her article, who has dementia and cannot speak or move his limbs, was refused despite letters from two specialists, a GP and an occupational therapist. My husband, 96, who has severe dementia and other problems requiring 24-hour monitoring, was also turned down.
There is further unfairness. Someone in a nursing home who has been refused free care can still receive a flat-rate NHS contribution, while someone cared for at home by family and paid carers receives no NHS equivalent. Ministers need not wait for a national care service. They could ensure that the national framework is applied consistently and introduce a part-funded tier, particularly where people are cared for at home.
Lynn Hieatt
Cambridge
Social Care – Burnham is asking the wrong question.
Addressing the back door… Social Care run well should help the health services….
